Reggie Bush Pushes Again, This Time To Bring the NCAA To Its Knees

Legal voices see plenty of weight in Reggie Bush’s case against the NCAA

Breaking down some of the key questions surrounding the former USC running back’s defamation lawsuit

Reggie Bush at L.A. Coliseum presser with attorneys Levi G. McCathern, right, and Ben Crump, left, to talk about Bush’s NCAA defamation lawsuit. (Photo by Hans Gutknecht, LADN/SCNG)

Luca Evans (OC Register)  —  In the early winter of 2019, following a string of legal battles that included a waiver for current Chicago Bears quarterback Justin Fields’ transfer from Georgia to Ohio State, lawyer Tom Mars (below) got a call from the NCAA requesting he join their “Complex Case Unit.” He was given a five-year contract, officially beginning that summer.

He left after one year.

The main reason, Mars said, was a disagreement with the NCAA’s conduct of investigations – largely with the NCAA’s lack of Supreme Court obligation to employ traditional due process rights.

“Their method of doing investigations is half-assed, and that’s on the record,” Mars said. “There’s no better way to put it.”

It was the same sentiment that formed the basis for biting remarks from Reggie Bush’s lawyers at an Aug. 23 press conference at the Coliseum, announcing a defamation suit against the NCAA and claiming the governing body’s original investigation into Bush – which led to the stripping of his Heisman Trophy and collegiate records – was “terrible work.”

Perhaps, in that moment, it would have been easy to paint such statements almost as slander: a public outcry held just hundreds of feet from the stretch of seats where Bush’s No. 5 should be commemorated, they argued.

But the credibility of Bush’s case, Mars said, comes within a string of holes poked over time in the NCAA’s original investigation. In 2015, in the midst of an investigation into former USC coach Todd McNair’s knowledge of violations surrounding Bush, the California Second District Court of Appeals held that the NCAA’s report on the case “was worded in disregard of the truth.”

So the NCAA’s widely-reported statement in 2021 alleging Bush had engaged in a “pay-for-play” scheme, Mars said, left the door open for Bush to wedge in a defamation suit that won’t just call for punitive damages – it will call into question the NCAA’s entire credibility in conducting investigations.

“I know if I were one of Reggie’s lawyers, I would have a pillar of my trial preparation being what all I just talked about … and that is why, in my opinion, the NCAA put themselves at risk,” Mars said.

The Southern California News Group spoke with Mars and two other lawyers, all with extensive backgrounds in high-profile litigation, for their professional insight on the path forward for Bush and the likely outcomes of a suit with massive implications. Here’s an analysis of some key questions.

What is Bush pushing for?

Simple answer, from Bush and his team at that August press conference: restore his Heisman Trophy glory. Restore his records. Win the fight he’s been fighting for over a decade.

But it’s clear, as personal injury lawyer David Ring said, that Bush’s goal is to not just win a case in court. He’s hired Ben Crump, one of the most visible litigators in the nation and an expert in weaponizing narrative, a man who launched incendiary phrases like “plantation mentality” against the NCAA in addressing media at the Coliseum. So a major part of Bush’s push, Ring said, is trying to galvanize public opinion – putting so much external pressure on the NCAA they back down before a lengthy legal battle.

Reggie Bush has one goal with bringing this lawsuit,” Ring said, “and that’s to bring the NCAA to its knees with respect to his situation.”

What, then, will the NCAA’s response be?

When asked about their planned response to Bush’s suit and confidence in their original investigation, the NCAA declined to comment for this story.

Their most immediate and obvious course of action, though, would be to file a motion to dismiss the case. Winning such a motion, Ring said, would be difficult.

If the NCAA didn’t win that motion, that would then induce a lengthy period of discovery before the case hit a jury – a fight that will take years of trial and error and hemorrhaging cash to defend its original stance. Would the NCAA, Ring questioned, really want to go that far?

Yes, according to Mit Winter, an attorney with a wide range of experience representing collegiate organizations in business disputes and athletes in name, image and likeness matters. The NCAA’s litigation strategy throughout history, Winter said, has been to fight to the death, rarely settling out of court.

“It just takes the position that, ‘We haven’t done anything wrong, we’re right, and therefore we’re going to litigate this until the last dog is dead,’” Mars said.

What’s the legal heft of Bush’s case?

In a vacuum, it’s quite difficult for a public figure to win a defamation suit, due to the need to prove malice behind the defendant’s statements.

It might be tough, then, for Bush to prove that malice standard with the NCAA’s “pay-for-play” comment, Ring said. But this case is about more than simple defamation, as every lawyer pointed out. It’s about cracking open a sealed history box to re-evaluate the NCAA’s original findings.

“Fifteen years later, he wants to talk about it? Okay, that’s fine,” said Brian Stewart, who represents Lloyd Lake, a former sports marketer who testified to the NCAA he had provided benefits to Bush while at USC. “But like I said, if he wants to re-litigate that case, I don’t know how that’s actually going to work.”

“I see this as a desperate attempt to get his Heisman back,” Stewart said of Bush, “and it includes a frivolous lawsuit against the NCAA.”

It’s far from frivolous, however, Mars and Ring said, referencing the outcome of the McNair trial in which the Second District Court of Appeals eviscerated the NCAA’s investigation. Another factor, too, as Crump and a high-profile legal team tackle Bush’s case: the NCAA’s general reputation has taken a massive hit amid name, image and likeness and conference realignment madness, Mars said.

“There’s never been a better time, since the Earth cooled, to be a plaintiff against the NCAA than right now,” Mars said.

What’s the likely outcome?

There’s no likely outcome in a public figure defamation case, lawyers said. However, Ring, Winter and Mars all expressed strong belief in Bush’s chances to win a legal victory that could shake the very foundation of the NCAA.

“We’re not at a card table in Las Vegas or anything,” Mars said, “but if I got to choose which side of the case I’d want to be on, I’d want to be on Reggie Bush’s side.”

ocregister.com

________

TrojanDailyBlog members  —  We always encourage you to add information, insight, divergent opinions, or new topics to the TDB that don’t necessarily pertain to any particular moderator post or member comment.

SUBSCRIBE HERE TO RECEIVE NOTICE OF NEW COMMENTS OR REPLIES.
Notify of
56 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Trojan5
Genius Member
Trojan5
Offline
September 6, 2023 5:07 pm

Here is a topic/ & possible hot take that may or may not be of interest to anyone. But here goes. I am not and have never been a fan of Dabo Sweeney. Is it possible that DBU wasn’t the problem at Clemson? Maybe, just maybe Dabo is a big part of the problem for the Tigers.

ATL D.D.S.
Noble Genius
ATL D.D.S.
Offline
September 7, 2023 4:42 am
Reply to  Allen Wallace

he has also had the problem of losing coordinators. maybe the new OC for clemson ain’t all that?

Chris
Major Genius
Chris
Offline
September 6, 2023 6:26 pm
Reply to  Trojan5

He does need to adjust to portal but the guy is a sure fire hall of fame coach. He has made the CFP 6 times with 2 championships. His legacy is set in stone.

Trojan5
Genius Member
Trojan5
Offline
September 6, 2023 8:22 pm
Reply to  Chris

Objectively you are right. But my dislike is subjective. I simply do not like the man.

TrojanMPA90
Noble Genius
TrojanMPA90
Offline
September 6, 2023 4:44 pm

Stanford under Harbaugh and Shaw was smug and thought they could beat us every year. So I would love to end our last conference game with them by whipping them.

Golden Trojan
Major Genius
Golden Trojan
Offline
September 6, 2023 4:03 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

I have had to witness a couple of classless crude half time shows by the Furd band. I have no respect for that school. They think they are the intellectual superior to USC and better at sports. They show that by being rude instead of respected rivals.

TrojanRJJ
Noble Genius
TrojanRJJ
Offline
September 6, 2023 1:41 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

The issue is indeed a large part Scott. The real problem was the Presidents who hired him and kept him on for six years. Despite the mess Scott left behind, the conference could have been saved IF (1) they had merged with the B12 when TX and OK left OR (2) the Presidents (save Folt) would have had any common business sense OR (3) if an experienced commissioner had been hired to replace Scott (instead, the PAC hired got GK, who candidly had no clue what he was doing or up against – I do not blame GK – he… Read more »

TrojanRJJ
Noble Genius
TrojanRJJ
Offline
September 6, 2023 1:49 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

Allen, I really think Prime is a collegiate coach, not a pro coach. And, he will be formidable. If Prime succeeds hugely this year, it will send major ripples through collegiate ball. Riley turned SC around in one year, with transfers and roster change; Prime did the same, only with THREE times the roster change that LR engaged in. It is possible that some new coach will bring a totally new roster with him in the near future. In the era of NIL, I could see a coach having significant NIL backing bringing in a totally new team. Should be… Read more »

Golden Trojan
Major Genius
Golden Trojan
Offline
September 6, 2023 3:56 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

I agree with Rjj, DS is great as a college football HC. He is a great motivator and can attract talent. Time will tell if he has the chops in big games. From what I read, NFL players tired quickly of rah rah coaches. It’s all business, tell us what to do, and we will do it as best we can.

RialtoTrojan
Noble Genius
RialtoTrojan
Offline
September 6, 2023 11:03 am

There hasn’t been much talk about the bogus Targeting call Saturday. I believe the number one tool to use against our defense this season is the penalty that carries an ejection the way Targeting does. Watching and rewatching the “foul” Saturday I saw two players lowering their heads at the same time, which resulted in incidental contact. With the removal of intent to harm from the rule, comes the completely unnecessary judgment call. If a defensive player is in the correct position to make a tackle, and the offensive player lowers his helmet at the right moment, the defensive player… Read more »

Rock2112
Noble Genius
Rock2112
Offline
September 6, 2023 11:38 am
Reply to  RialtoTrojan

To me, what is missing from the targeting rule is two levels as we have for face mask and roughing the kicker penalties in the NFL (i.e., 5 yard and 15 yard variety). The targeting rule should stay as is, and only be applied to true cases where the defender clearly goes head-hunting, and there should be a 10-yard penalty for incidental contact to the head that does not carry ejection. That is enough to encourage avoiding the contact, and only egregious cases then result in sitting a player. And, by the way, in this scheme, every ejection should come… Read more »

ATL D.D.S.
Noble Genius
ATL D.D.S.
Offline
September 6, 2023 4:13 pm
Reply to  Rock2112

you are making too much sense for the minions at the NCAA, Rock. No soap.

TrojanRJJ
Noble Genius
TrojanRJJ
Offline
September 6, 2023 9:02 am

I just finished watching “Swamp Kings” on Netflicks. It is the story of Urban Meyer’s run at FL. It is also an excellent inside look at a major collegiate football program. I highly recommend it. Language is a bit rough for those offended by such things. Several things really struck me. I think the first is the impact on the kids. Urban talked about his major regret as a coach. One of his kids got involved in a domestic violence dispute – he hit his girlfriend (a very common problem, which I totally condemn but I think our society mangles… Read more »

Steveg
Major Genius
Steveg
Offline
September 6, 2023 9:22 am
Reply to  TrojanRJJ

Spot on RJ. The elites are now not only accustomed to the attention, it has grown into the desire for lots of money because they are so good. I am paying attention to who turned down USC from MD, and want to see how they come out at the school they chose. Was the money worth it? Did they develop into the player they needed to be?

ATL D.D.S.
Noble Genius
ATL D.D.S.
Offline
September 5, 2023 6:43 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

Fight On, Gino. We are pulling for your full recovery.

USC1988
Noble Genius
USC1988
Offline
September 5, 2023 8:14 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

Who is back up center ?

Steveg
Major Genius
Steveg
Offline
September 6, 2023 9:10 am
Reply to  USC1988

I think the depth chart showed Killian O’Connor, a soph.

Steveg
Major Genius
Steveg
Offline
September 5, 2023 5:36 pm

Gino out for the season.

USC1988
Noble Genius
USC1988
Offline
September 5, 2023 8:12 pm
Reply to  Steveg

Bad loss … frosh will need to grow in a hurry

Steveg
Major Genius
Steveg
Offline
September 5, 2023 4:27 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

I hope so. I want Nebraska back when USC goes into their conference.

USC1988
Noble Genius
USC1988
Offline
September 5, 2023 8:11 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

Early start, CU riding high not ready to play, Prime too busy talking shit … Huskers simply don’t know how to win and will lose a close one here too. But it will be scary for CU.

TrojanRon
Noble Genius
TrojanRon
Offline
September 6, 2023 5:55 am
Reply to  Allen Wallace

Allen: thank you for sharing Rod Serling’s background. I didn’t know much about him, but certainly remember his distinctive voice as he opened the TV Show “The Twilight Zone”. I remember when NEB was basking in the light in 1971-72 when they won National Championships. I’ll never forget UCLA going to NEB in 1973 and running all over them using the “Wishbone T” Offense with Mark Harmon, a.k.a. Leroy Jethro Gibbs of NCIS, at QB for the Bruins. Pepper Rodgers was UCLA’s HC. Without “Googling” and as my memory serves, I think UCLA steamrolled NEB something like 63-10. That same… Read more »

Golden Trojan
Major Genius
Golden Trojan
Offline
September 5, 2023 12:21 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

Notice the highest ranked Big12 is Texas @#11 and Alabama will knock them down this Saturday. Looks like the winner of the Pac12 should get a playoff spot is they don’t lose more than a game or maybe 2.

TrojanRJJ
Noble Genius
TrojanRJJ
Offline
September 5, 2023 12:48 pm
Reply to  Golden Trojan

GT,hope you are correct. It is very possible that the winner of the PAC will have at least two losses. While we all hope for 12-0 for SC, I just do not see it happening when we play six top 25 teams and UCLA.

TrojanRJJ
Noble Genius
TrojanRJJ
Offline
September 5, 2023 12:44 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

Boy, do we ever have a brutal schedule! I do not worry about rankings until much later in the season, but based on what I have seen so far: Oregon State. It did not just beat SJS. They brutalized them. I turned it off in the 3rd Q because it reminded me of an execution rather than a game. This team will be a load for every team it plays. It is a team that plays and is put together a lot like Utah. I would NOT want to play them in Corvallis. CO: A clone of the 2022 Trojans… Read more »

HOF19
Noble Genius
HOF19
Offline
September 5, 2023 10:45 am
Reply to  Allen Wallace

Totally expected FSU to get jumped over SC ….. But to me it is not where we are on September 5 2023 ….. But where we are say ….This coming X-mas morning ………. FIGHT ON !!!!!

HOF19
Noble Genius
HOF19
Offline
September 5, 2023 11:09 am
Reply to  Allen Wallace

Allen I lean on this being a rankings “problem” for the next few weeks for SC when you said >>>>> ” Or maybe USC would have been leapfrogged by FSU anyway because we don’t play anyone any good until ND.”

HOF19
Noble Genius
HOF19
Offline
September 5, 2023 12:14 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

Allen when I think of Sports subjects under the category of “Biggest screw-ups EVER ” I look at today’s AP Poll Announcement where they have USC at #6 ….. Washington #8 ….. Utah #12….. Oregon #13 ….. Ore St #16….. Colo #22 and under the AP POLL Category ” OTHERS RECEIVING VOTES:” UCLA (BOO) And even Wash St . And THAT’S THE CONFERENCE THAT DISSOLVES ?????…I mean I gotta nominate it as Worst Conference management EVER !!!!!

Golden Trojan
Major Genius
Golden Trojan
Offline
September 5, 2023 12:16 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

SC might get a boost in 4 weeks if Colorado still looks decent. But now is the time to sit people who are making mistakes, play the #1s, and run up the scores to make a case they are a top 5.

By the way, what a nice problem to have, it’s great to be a Trojan again!

Golden Trojan
Major Genius
Golden Trojan
Offline
September 5, 2023 12:43 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

He’s got his new “warriors” that took it to the mighty FCS, 4-7, Citadel!

Steveg
Major Genius
Steveg
Offline
September 5, 2023 1:37 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

Allen, I think we agree that Colorado may be fairly good, but it seems to me that depth will be their downfall, as it was at USC last year.

volunteerTrojan
Major Genius
September 5, 2023 3:41 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

Probably wouldn’t have changed the rankings, but certainly it hasn’t helped having the nation’s best football player on essentially a private inaccessible network for most of the nation for the first two games, plus starting at 10:30pm this coming Saturday. The soon-to-be-dead p12 couldn’t do a worse job of promoting its teams if it tried.

Steveg
Major Genius
Steveg
Offline
September 5, 2023 1:34 pm
Reply to  Allen Wallace

Who says FSU played anyone good? LSU looked on par with San Jose St. It is only because everyone put LSU there based on last year or Kelly’s reputation. Now they are exposed. The voters lose face if they drop LSU beyond 14, where they should be down with Clemson in the twenties. Man, I hate early polls. Have I already said that?

RialtoTrojan
Noble Genius
RialtoTrojan
Offline
September 5, 2023 9:21 am

The NCAA has a skewed sense of righteousness, which can and should shut it down forever. With the recent court backed rules changes and losses in court, the NCAA has become a useless slug.
Through the myth of amateur athletes and presumed ability to control student movement, the NCAA has built an empire of unfairness. The end cannot come soon enough. I predict the realigned football landscape will bring an end to the NCAA in the next five years with the league’s governing themselves and the Bush case will be the catalyst for change.

Steveg
Major Genius
Steveg
Offline
September 5, 2023 9:11 am

In the far off future can we look forward to the great grand children of Reggie Bush go to court to get his Heisman trophy returned. Will this saga ever end?

ATL D.D.S.
Noble Genius
ATL D.D.S.
Offline
September 5, 2023 10:38 am
Reply to  Steveg

it won’t take that long….